Submitted to: Contest #305

When the Nightmare Ends

Written in response to: "It took a few seconds to realize I was utterly and completely lost."

Drama Fiction Horror

I took a few seconds to realize I was utterly and completely lost.


Not lost in the woods, or lost in a city I didn't recognize.


No, this was a deeper, far more unsettling lostness.


It was the kind that gnawed at the edges of your perception, a phantom limb ache for a reality that had just… vanished.


My last memory, sharp as a freshly honed blade, was of plunging my gloved hand, claws extended, into the chest of some screaming teenager.


A typical Tuesday night, really.


The usual fear, the usual delightful spray of crimson. Then, blackness.


Not the comforting, familiar black of the dream world, but an absolute void, devoid of even the faintest whisper of terror.


Now, here I was. Or, here I was.


The "here" was the real problem. It was… a room.


A perfectly ordinary room, which, for me, was about as jarring as a nun in a mosh pit. Floral wallpaper, for crying out loud. Muted pastels. A twin bed with a knitted throw.


A dresser with a doily. My mind, usually a chaotic symphony of screams and sadistic glee, struggled to process the sheer mundaneity of it all.


I looked down at my hands. They were… normal.


Five fingers. No claws.


No burns. Just pale, unblemished skin. I flexed them.


They felt alien. I ran them over my face. Smooth. No disfiguring scars, no raw, exposed muscle.


I scrambled to a mirror on the wall, a small oval affair.


Staring back at me was not the familiar, terrifying visage of Freddy Krueger, but… a man.


A young man, even.


With a shock of brown hair, blue eyes that held a flicker of unfamiliar panic, and a smattering of freckles across his nose.


"What in the hell?" I muttered, and the voice that emerged was not my gravelly, venomous rasp, but a lighter, less menacing tone.


It was my voice, yes, but scrubbed clean, like a slate wiped free of all its gruesome history.


Panic, a sensation I rarely experienced from this side of the equation, began to bubble.


This wasn't a dream. I knew dreams.


I molded them, twisted them, used them as my personal hunting ground.


This felt… concrete.


Solid.


The air smelled of lemon polish and something vaguely floral, not the metallic tang of fear or the sweet decay of nightmares.


I tried to summon my powers, to twist the doily into a writhing snake, to make the floral patterns bleed.


Nothing.


My will, once absolute within the dreamscape, bounced off this mundane reality like a pebble against a steel wall.


It was like trying to breathe underwater.


I walked to the window.


Outside, a perfectly manicured suburban street. Kids on bikes, a dog barking somewhere in the distance. The sun, offensively bright, cast long shadows.


There was a sense of… peace. It was utterly repugnant.


Where were the shadows?


Where were the fear-soaked alleys, the flickering streetlights that promised lurking horrors?


This was too clean, too… innocent. It made my non-existent skin crawl.


My memory, usually a perfectly indexed catalogue of every victim, every moment of their terror, was fractured.


I knew who I was.


I knew I was Freddy Krueger.


The Springwood Slasher.


The nightmare demon.


But the details were hazy, like looking through a smeared windowpane.


My origin, my power, the way I operated – it was all there, but disconnected, like facts in a textbook rather than lived experience.


A sudden, sharp headache lanced through my temples.


Images flickered behind my eyes: a boiler room, flames, a familiar glove.


Then, screams. Always screams.


But they were distant, muffled, like echoes from another lifetime.


I tried to focus, to pierce the veil of this maddening normalcy.


"This isn't real," I whispered, the words tasting like ash.


"This is a trick. A dream. Someone's trying to play games with me."


But the conviction wasn't there.


There was an unsettling quiet in my mind, a void where the incessant whispers of fear and the tantalizing scent of fresh terror should have been.


It was like a radio that had gone dead.


Days bled into what felt like weeks, though I had no real way of telling time in this sterile prison.


There was food left at a small table by the door – bland, healthy meals. Water.


No one spoke to me.


No one came in.


It was as if I was being observed, kept in a pristine, gilded cage.


I tried everything. I slammed my fists against the walls, hoping to break through some invisible barrier.


I screamed until my throat was raw, hoping to conjure some echo of the nightmare world. I tried to mentally warp the objects in the room, to make them horrific, to bring the familiar dread to this place.


Nothing.


The doily remained a doily. The floral wallpaper stayed floral. The bed remained a bed.


The frustration was a physical ache.


I, Freddy Krueger, master of fear, lord of nightmares, was utterly, completely helpless.


The irony was not lost on me, and it bit deeper than any bladed glove.


One "morning," as I was picking listlessly at a plate of oatmeal, a small, square device lay beside it.


It was thin, with a glowing screen. A tablet, I vaguely recalled. A tool for… information.


My hands, still disarmingly normal, trembled slightly as I picked it up.


The screen lit up, displaying a simple interface. A search bar. I stared at it, my mind a churning maelstrom of confusion and nascent terror.


What would I even search for?


Who am I? Why am I here?


How do I get my claws back?


I typed, slowly, with a strange hesitancy, "Freddy Krueger."


The results loaded almost instantly.


My eyes scanned the screen, and a cold, visceral dread began to coil in my gut.


It was all there.


The history. The boiler room.


The children. The deaths.


The movies.


Movies.


My gaze snapped to that word.


There were images.


Posters. Promotional shots.


And then, the horrifying truth began to dawn.


My face, my true face, was plastered across these digital pages, accompanied by names like "Robert Englund."


This wasn't just a physical transformation. It was a complete unraveling of my reality.


I wasn't just a boogeyman, a demonic entity.


I was a character, a fictional construct.


"No," I whispered, my voice cracking.


"No, this is wrong. This is a lie."


But the evidence was overwhelming.


Articles detailed my "franchise," my "lore," my "cultural impact." They talked about my "origins" as if they were carefully crafted narratives, not the raw, burning truth of my existence.


They dissected my "psychology," my "motives," as if I were a puzzle to be solved, not an unstoppable force of vengeance.


The headache intensified, a relentless pounding behind my eyes.


Memories, twisted and fragmented, crashed over me. The joy of carving flesh, the exquisite agony of my victims, the raw power of existing solely to inflict terror – they were all there, but they felt… distant.


Like watching a film of my own life.


Could it be?


Could I have been nothing more than… a story?


A figment of someone else's twisted imagination?


The thought was more horrifying than any death I had ever inflicted. It wasn't just losing my powers; it was losing my very essence.


I scrolled further, desperate for a loophole, a sign that this was all a grand illusion. But it only deepened the abyss.


Fan theories. Merchandise.


Video games where I was a playable character.


It was an entire industry built upon me.


My rage, usually a roaring inferno, was a cold, impotent ash.


What was the point of being the ultimate nightmare if you weren't even real?


If your existence was confined to screens and pages?


The initial shock gave way to a chilling emptiness. I was Freddy Krueger, but I wasn't.


The man in the mirror was a stranger, and the reality I now inhabited was a cruel parody of my own. I was a puppet, the strings cut, the stage dismantled.


One "day," I was startled by the sound of a key turning in the lock.


The door opened slowly, revealing a woman in a crisp white lab coat. She had kind eyes, which only served to irritate me further. My usual response would have been a quick, brutal end.


But I was powerless.


"Hello, Freddy," she said, her voice soft and calm. "How are you feeling today?"


My blood ran cold.


"Freddy?" I rasped, the name feeling foreign on this new tongue.


"You know me?"


She smiled gently. "Of course. We've been taking care of you."


"Taking care of me?" My voice rose.


"You've imprisoned me! You've taken everything!"


"We've been helping you transition," she corrected, her voice unwavering. "To accept your new reality."


"New reality?" I scoffed.


"This isn't reality! This is some sick joke!"


She pulled up a chair and sat opposite me, her composure unnervingly serene.


"Freddy, you've been through a lot. You've experienced… significant dissociation. We understand it's disorienting."


"Dissociation?" I barked a laugh, hollow and devoid of humor.


"I'm the master of dissociation! I lived in the dreams!"


"And that's precisely what we're helping you with," she said. "The line between your internal world and the external world blurred significantly. You believed you were a character from a popular horror franchise."


My jaw dropped.


"Believed? I am him! I am Freddy Krueger!"


She sighed, a subtle weariness in her expression.


"Your brain created a very elaborate, very convincing narrative. But it wasn't real. You're a human being, Freddy. A very troubled one, but human nonetheless."


The word hit me with the force of a physical blow.


Human.


The most disgusting, fragile, pathetic creatures in existence.


The very beings I delighted in tormenting.


And now, I was one of them.


"My scars," I whispered, touching my smooth face.


"My claws. My power."


"All part of the narrative your mind constructed," she explained patiently. "A coping mechanism, perhaps, for underlying trauma. We're working to help you process that trauma and integrate into a healthy, functional life."


My mind reeled.


Trauma? Coping mechanism?


These were the terms of the weak, the vulnerable.


Not me. Never me.


"Who am I, then?" I asked, the question a raw, desperate plea.


"If I'm not Freddy Krueger, then who the hell am I?"


She leaned forward, her gaze earnest.


"You're Frederick Charles Krueger. You've been in our care for some time. We believe you're making good progress. You're showing signs of accepting your true identity."


Frederick Charles Krueger.


The name tasted bland, utterly without flavor.


It lacked the menace, the terror, the sheer weight of "Freddy Krueger."


"What about the boiler room?" I pressed, clinging to the last vestiges of my self-proclaimed reality.


"The children? The murders?"


Her expression softened with a pity that infuriated me. "Those are vivid, terrifying experiences you've created within your mind. They're symptoms of your condition, not actual events."


"You're lying," I snarled, a flicker of my old fury stirring.


"You're trying to brainwash me! To strip me of who I am!"


"We're trying to help you heal," she countered calmly. "To live a life free from the burden of those delusions."


Delusions.


The word hung in the air, a cruel, mocking epitaph to my former existence.


I was a delusion. A figment.


A bad dream that had somehow escaped the confines of sleep and landed in the waking world, only to be diagnosed and treated.


The sessions continued. She, Dr. Evans, talked about "cognitive restructuring," about "grounding exercises," about "reintegrating into society."


I listened, or pretended to, my mind a storm of denial and despair. I yearned for the smell of burning flesh, the taste of fear, the familiar warmth of freshly spilled blood.


I tried to fight it. I would close my eyes and try to summon the nightmare, to find the pathways back to my true home. But it was like trying to recall a dream upon waking – fleeting, elusive, and ultimately out of reach.


The more I tried, the more this sterile reality asserted itself.


One day, she brought in a newspaper. "Frederick, I think it's time you started engaging with the world again. We have a small job opening here at the facility. Simple, administrative tasks. It would be a good first step."


My eyes scanned the headlines: local news, weather, sports.


Mundane, utterly boring. I looked at the job description.


Administrative assistant. Me. Freddy Krueger.


Taking dictation. Filing papers.


The sheer absurdity of it made my stomach churn.


"I kill people," I said, my voice flat.


"I revel in their terror. I don't file papers."


She smiled, a hint of sadness in her eyes. "You believed you did. And we're working on that. But the truth is, you've never harmed anyone in this reality, Frederick."


Never harmed anyone. The words echoed in my mind, a chilling pronouncement of my ultimate impotence.


All those years, all that power, all that exquisite torment – it was all a lie.


A grand, self-created illusion.


The realization settled deep in my bones, a cold, heavy weight.


The horror wasn't that I was trapped in this mundane world; it was that the world I had known, the world where I was a god, had never truly existed outside my own fractured mind.


I was utterly and completely lost.


Not lost in a new reality, but lost from the one I had constructed, the one that had defined my every atom. And the most terrifying part was that there was no going back.


The dream was over, and I was just… Frederick Charles Krueger.


A man. With a job.


And a history that was nothing more than a carefully constructed delusion.


The last shred of my old self, the core of my identity, dissolved into the bland reality of floral wallpaper and administrative tasks.


And in that moment, I finally understood the true meaning of powerlessness.

Posted Jun 02, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

16 likes 10 comments

William Braden
03:28 Jun 09, 2025

I loved this twist. It kept me reading to the end, magnificent.

Reply

J.R. Geiger
16:09 Jun 09, 2025

Thank you for the kind words.

Reply

Charlie Murphy
00:49 Jun 09, 2025

I love the unique spin you did with Freddy.

Reply

J.R. Geiger
16:14 Jun 09, 2025

Thank you!

Reply

Nicole Moir
10:24 Jun 08, 2025

This is such an amazing idea. I love the tense and how the internal dialogue and thoughts came across clearly. I always find stories with MC who don't know where they are can be slow, but yours was fast-paced and engaging.

Reply

J.R. Geiger
15:00 Jun 08, 2025

Thank you!

Reply

Brutus Clement
21:20 Jun 03, 2025

I like the immediacy of now present in this story---A very unique structure --- I always like first person narrative and think it would be more powerful to keep it all in present tense---interesting work!

Reply

J.R. Geiger
23:56 Jun 03, 2025

Thank you!

It's interesting to write in the first person.

Did I miss something in my story? You mentioned keeping it in the present tense.

Reply

Brutus Clement
00:27 Jun 04, 2025

no you didn't miss anything, It's just that personally I find it more powerful to say "I look" rather than "I looked"---- or "I see" rather than "I saw"----the present tense makes the reader feel more connected to the actions the character is going through---but that's just my prejudice

Reply

J.R. Geiger
01:40 Jun 04, 2025

Thank you so much!!

Appreciate the feedback.

I really enjoy writing these stories and folks enjoying them too.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.